India's government scrambles to block a film about Modi's role in anti-Muslim riots
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi waits Wednesday for the arrival of Egyptian President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi at Hyderabad house, in New Delhi, India. Manish Swarup/AP hide caption
toggle caption Manish Swarup/AP Manish Swarup/APNEW DELHI — Days after India blocked a BBC documentary that examines Prime Minister Narendra Modi's role during 2002 anti-Muslim riots and banned people from sharing it online, authorities are scrambling to halt screenings of the program at colleges and universities and restrict clips of it on social media, a move that has been decried by critics as an assault on press freedom.
Tensions escalated in the capital, New Delhi, on Wednesday at Jamia Millia University, where a student group said it planned to screen the banned documentary, prompting dozens of police equipped with tear gas and riot gear to gather outside campus gates.
Sponsor MessagePolice, some in plain clothes, scuffled with protesting students and detained at least half a dozen, who were taken away in a van.
"This is the time for Indian youth to put up the truth which everybody knows. We know what the prime minister is doing to the society," said Liya Shareef, 20, a geography student and member of the student group Fraternity Movement.
Jawaharlal Nehru University in the capital cut off power and the internet on its campus on Tuesday before the documentary was scheduled to be screened by a students' union. Authorities said it would disturb peace on campus, but students nonetheless watched the documentary on their laptops and mobile phones after sharing it on messaging services such as Telegram and WhatsApp.
The documentary has caused a storm at other Indian universities too.
Authorities at the University of Hyderabad, in India's south, began a probe after a student group showed the banned documentary earlier this week. In the southern state of Kerala, workers from Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party held demonstrations on Tuesday after some student groups affiliated with rival political parties defied the ban and screened the program.
Parallels Narendra Modi: From a humble start to India's prime ministerThe two-part documentary "India: The Modi Question" has not been broadcast in India by the BBC, but India's federal government blocked it over the weekend and banned people from sharing clips on social media, citing emergency powers under its information technology laws. Twitter and YouTube complied with the request and removed many links to the documentary.
The first part of the program, released last week by the BBC for its U.K. audiences, revives the most controversial episode of Modi's political career when he was the chief minister of western Gujarat state in 2002. It focuses on anti-Muslim riots in which more than 1,000 people were killed.
Sponsor MessageThe riots have long hounded Modi because of allegations that authorities under his watch allowed and even encouraged the bloodshed. Modi has denied the accusations, and the Supreme Court has said it found no evidence to prosecute him. Last year, the country's top court dismissed a petition filed by a Muslim victim questioning Modi's exoneration.
The first part of the BBC documentary relies on interviews with victims of the riots, journalists and rights activists, who say Modi looked the other way during the riots. It cites, for the first time, a secret British diplomatic investigation that concluded Modi was "directly responsible" for the "climate of impunity."
Faith and power: How Hindu Nationalism is changing IndiaThe documentary includes the testimony of then-British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw, who says the British investigation found that the violence by Hindu nationalists aimed to "purge Muslims from Hindu areas" and that it had all the "hallmarks of an ethnic cleansing."
Suspicions that Modi quietly supported the riots led the U.S., U.K. and E.U. to deny him a visa, a move that has since been reversed.
India's Foreign Ministry last week called the documentary a "propaganda piece designed to push a particularly discredited narrative" that lacks objectivity, and slammed it for "bias" and "a continuing colonial mindset." Kanchan Gupta, a senior adviser in the government's Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, denounced it as "anti-India garbage."
The BBC in a statement said the documentary was "rigorously researched" and involved a wide range of voices and opinions.
"We offered the Indian Government a right to reply to the matters raised in the series — it declined to respond," the statement said.
The second part of the documentary, released Tuesday in the U.K., "examines the track record of Narendra Modi's government following his re-election in 2019," according to the film's description on the BBC website.
Enlarge this imageStudents watch security personnel guard the main gate of Jamia Millia Islamia university Wednesday in New Delhi, India. A student group said it planned to screen a banned documentary that examines Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's role during 2002 anti-Muslim riots, prompting dozens of police equipped with tear gas and riot gear to gather outside campus gates. Manish Swarup/AP hide caption
toggle caption Manish Swarup/AP Manish Swarup/APIn recent years, India's Muslim minority has been at the receiving end of violence from Hindu nationalists, emboldened by a prime minister who has mostly stayed mum on such attacks since he was first elected in 2014.
Sponsor MessageThe ban has set off a wave of criticism from opposition parties and rights groups that slammed it as an attack against press freedom. It also drew more attention to the documentary, sparking scores of social media users to share clips on WhatsApp, Telegram and Twitter.
"You can ban, you can suppress the press, you can control the institutions ... but the truth is the truth. It has a nasty habit of coming out," Rahul Gandhi, a leader of the opposition Congress party, told reporters at a news conference Tuesday.
Mahua Moitra, a lawmaker from the Trinamool Congress political party, on Tuesday tweeted a new link to the documentary after a previous one was taken down. "Good, bad, or ugly — we decide. Govt doesn't tell us what to watch," Moitra said in her tweet, which was still up Wednesday morning.
Goats and Soda The Gates Foundation's 2019 humanitarian award to Modi sparked outrageHuman Rights Watch said the ban reflected a broader crackdown on minorities under the Modi government, which the rights group said has frequently invoked draconian laws to muzzle criticism.
Critics say press freedom in India has declined in recent years and the country fell eight places, to 150 out of 180 countries, in last year's Press Freedom Index published by Reporters Without Borders. It accuses Modi's government of silencing criticism on social media, particularly on Twitter, a charge senior leaders of the governing party have denied.
Modi's government has regularly pressured Twitter to restrict or ban content it deems critical of the prime minister or his party. Last year, it threatened to arrest Twitter staff in the country over their refusal to ban accounts run by critics after implementing sweeping new regulations for technology and social media companies.
The ban on the BBC documentary comes after a proposal from the government to give its Press Information Bureau and other "fact-checking" agencies powers to take down news deemed "fake or false" from digital platforms.
Sponsor MessageThe Editors Guild of India urged the government to withdraw the proposal, saying such a change would be akin to censorship.
Censorship BBC India narendra modi gujarat-
More than 80 people have been rescued from a Philippine ferry fireJason Reynolds: How Can We Connect With Kids Through The Written Word?NPR Exclusive: Troubled Public Service Loan Forgiveness program will get overhaulThe U.S. needs more nurses, but nursing schools don't have enough slotsPeople in Tokyo wait in line 3 hours for a taste of these Japanese rice ballsCalifornia will require all schoolchildren to get a COVID vaccine once fully approvedThe superstar teachers of our Student Podcast ChallengeCOMIC: If history is a guide, schools will start requiring COVID vaccinesA ferry fire in the Philippines leaves more than 30 dead, a governor saysBiden Brushes Off The GOP Threats To Sue Over Vaccine Mandates
下一篇:'Greek Lessons' is an intimate, vulnerable portrayal of two lonely people
- ·After snub by Taylor Swift, Filipino 'Swifties' find solace in another Taylor
- ·How To Talk About 9/11 With A New Generation Of Kids
- ·She's Been Teaching For 18 Years. She Says This Year Is Her Most Stressful Yet
- ·The superstar teachers of our Student Podcast Challenge
- ·North Korea's Kim orders 'exponential' expansion of nuclear arsenal
- ·Caught Between Parents And Politicians, Nurses Fear Another School Year With COVID-19
- ·California plans to replace a toppled statue with a monument to Native Americans
- ·Florida Is Blocking Money From 2 School Districts Over Mask Mandates, Defying A Judge
- ·Japan's atomic bomb survivors hope G-7 firms up support for nuclear disarmament
- ·Another Sign Of The Pandemic's Effect On College Students: Fewer Transfers
- ·Planet Money Summer School 6: Crypto & Commencement
- ·Another Sign Of The Pandemic's Effect On College Students: Fewer Transfers
- ·Two new books challenge the sense of inevitable permanence of the Chinese party state
- ·She guarded the Black Lives Matter memorial. Now, she's working to protect its art
- ·Alexis Nikole Nelson: How Foraging Restored My Relationship With Food
- ·Schools Are Getting Billions In COVID Relief Money. Here's How They Plan To Spend It
- ·His baby gene editing shocked ethicists. Now he's in the lab again
- ·More Than 45,000 Louisiana Students Could Be Out Of School Until October Due To Ida
- ·California plans to replace a toppled statue with a monument to Native Americans
- ·A School Board Will Pay $1.3M Over A Trans Student's Lawsuit Against Its Bathroom Ban
- ·People in Tokyo wait in line 3 hours for a taste of these Japanese rice balls
- ·Parents Of Children With Disabilities Join The Legal Battle Over Masks In Schools
- ·How reading aloud can help you bond with your kids and make them better readers
- ·Biden Dangles New Federal Funds For Schools That Defy Mask Mandate Bans
- ·In Afghanistan, coal mining relies on the labor of children
- ·Textbook that asked if treatment of Native Americans was 'exaggerated' is recalled
- ·Editors' picks: Our best global photos of 2022 range from heart-rending to hopeful
- ·Day care for disabled children requires better funding, parents and experts say
- ·Florida Students Are No Longer Required To Quarantine After Being Exposed To COVID
- ·Howard University Partially Reopens As It Investigates A Cyberattack
- ·China plans to use chemicals to generate rain to protect its grain harvest
- ·6 Strategies To Make Classrooms Safer As The Delta Variant Spreads
- ·Whatever Happened To ... The Woman Whose Mission Is To Get African Girls In School?
- ·COMIC: If history is a guide, schools will start requiring COVID vaccines
- ·'Fragile Cargo' chronicles the quest to save China's Forbidden City treasures from war
- ·He always wanted a Ph.D. in physics. He finally earned it at 89